I loved the first book in this series–Wendy Darling: Stars, previously reviewed here. Based on the ending of Stars and the title Seas, I had an idea of what (or whom) this book would feature, but like the first book, there were unexpected twists and turns.
SPOILER WARNING: This review will contain spoilers for the first book in the series.
THE PLOT: Wendy and Michael have been fished out of the sea by Captain Hook’s crew. Wendy figures they won’t be much safer in the hands of pirates than they were with evil, self-centered Peter, but she’ll do anything to keep Michael safe. The pirates, especially a nasty one named Smith, assure Wendy that they’d just as soon kill her as use her in their battle against Peter. When Wendy is brought to Captain James Hook, he promises his only interest in her is how she can help him defeat Peter. Yes, Peter is a homicidal maniac, but he’s obsessed with Wendy. Hook can use that weakness to his advantage. First, he needs to bring Wendy up to speed on his own turbulent history with Peter, and what Peter’s connection to Tink really is.
Wendy is all too aware of the precariousness of her situation. She would do anything to get her brother John away from Peter’s influence and get the Darlings back home to their parents…and Wendy’s first love, Booth. But Wendy’s time with the pirates will make her stronger physically and mentally, even while she faces horrible betrayals and mortal danger.
MY TWO CENTS: What do you need to know? First, Peter hardly appears in this book, except for the threat of knowing he’s out there watching. This one is centered firmly on the pirate ship Sudden Night, and it does a nice job of exploring the pirates.
We’ve seen various versions of Hook in many different versions of Peter Pan, but this one is different. He’s a very rounded character, neither all bad nor all good. He makes sure Wendy knows that he would have no problem disposing of her, yet they forge a friendship of sorts. Hook is firmly a pirate, but his actions may be an effort to actually save everyone. He is a man with very deep emotional ties to some people and studied indifference to everyone else. It’s almost easier to say which versions of Hook he is NOT, including the Disney version, the “Once Upon a Time” handsome anti-hero version, and the Dustin Hoffman version.
Wendy goes through quite a bit of development in this one, although she blushes entirely too often. (We get it, she’s on a pirate ship, the pirates not exactly going to respect her delicate sensibilities.) But where Hook’s primary goal is to destroy Peter, Wendy’s primary goal is to get home, safely, with both her brothers. Peter is just an obstacle, but he’s a fairly big, dangerous obstacle. It’s in Wendy’s best interest to ally with Hook and risk her life. It’s not just for him, or even for Neverland; as far as she’s concerned, those are just byproducts of her mission.
This does at times feel very much like the middle part of the story. For example, there are some overlong descriptions of the ship, and there are times where nothing is really happening, although those times help build tension. (Are the pirates good or bad? Is Peter lurking around the corner?) But the climax of the book is all up to Wendy, and her strength carries her through to a final twisting shock as a setup for the next book.
COVER NOTES: I love these covers. I love how you never see Wendy’s face, and the pleasing colors are reminiscent of the iconic blue nightgown we relate to Disney’s version of Wendy. I have to wonder if we’ll finally see Wendy’s face on the cover of the third and final book, as I’m sure she will rise as the conquering hero. So far, both covers show Wendy being pushed and pulled by the elements; I expect Wendy to become the element of the last book! Honestly, I like these covers so much that I will probably buy a set in paperback as well as the eformats I already have.
BOTTOM LINE: While bonding with Hook over their mutual loathing of Peter Pan, Wendy starts to become the player instead of the pawn. It’s obviously the middle of the story, but if you loved Stars, you’ll fall right into this one, too.
TEACUP RATING: Four out of five teacups.
ON SALE DATE: Available September 20, 2016, in paperback and eformats.
NEXT UP IN THE SERIES: Wendy Darling: Shadow, book 3 in the series, will be published in Fall 2017. I’m looking forward to the Wendy/Peter showdown.
Note: Review is based on an ARC provided by the publisher via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.